Experienced. Aggressive. Trial Lawyers.
★★★★★ 5.0 on Google  ·  (451 reviews)
2026 Award-Winning Criminal Defense Attorneys
Call Now  ·  (401) 269-3381  ·  Available 24/7
Award-Winning Defense
★★★★★ 5.0 Verified Rating
CALL 24/7
Marin & Murphy Law Firm · Partner

Stefanie A.
Murphy, Esq.

Partner — Rhode Island Criminal Defense Attorney

Attorney Stefanie A. Murphy is a Partner at Marin & Murphy Law Firm and one of Rhode Island's most recognized criminal defense attorneys — with 20 years of experience, 2,500+ DUI cases defended, and 14 consecutive years of Super Lawyers recognition. In October 2023, she secured a complete NOT GUILTY verdict in State v. Derek Winslow, a high-profile Providence Superior Court murder trial where her client faced charges alongside two co-conspirators who were already serving life sentences. She is the editor and contributing author of "A Practical Guide to Trying DUI Cases in Rhode Island" (MCLE, 2024) — the definitive DUI defense guide used by attorneys across New England. Throughout her career, Attorney Murphy has also served as a town solicitor — handling criminal prosecution on behalf of Rhode Island municipalities — giving her the same prosecution-side perspective that defines this firm's approach to every case.

20+Years in Practice
2,500+DUI Cases Defended
14Super Lawyers Years
NOT GUILTYMurder Acquittal · 2023
MCLEPublished DUI Author · 2024

20 Years. Published Author. Murder Trial Acquittal.

Attorney Stefanie A. Murphy built her career with a conviction shared by her partner Matthew Marin: that the most effective criminal defense requires understanding the system from every angle. From her first year of practice, she handled the full range of state and federal criminal matters — DUI, domestic violence, violent crimes, drug offenses, and federal cases — developing the trial-level instincts and constitutional sophistication she brings to every client today. Throughout her career, she has also served as a town solicitor for Rhode Island municipalities, handling criminal prosecution on behalf of local governments alongside her defense practice. That dual experience — prosecuting and defending — gives her the prosecution-side perspective that defines this firm's strategic advantage in every case.

Over 20 years, Attorney Murphy has defended more than 2,500 DUI and criminal cases across every Rhode Island court — from first-offense DUI at District Court to Superior Court murder trials to federal proceedings in U.S. District Court. Her practice spans DUI defense, violent crimes, domestic violence, drug offenses, sexual assault, and federal criminal matters. She handles cases through every stage: from the first phone call after an arrest through motion practice, evidentiary hearings, jury trial, and appeal.

Attorney Murphy has been regularly quoted by the Providence Journal and Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly on DUI law, constitutional criminal procedure, DNA post-conviction litigation, and high-profile criminal cases — demonstrating the depth of recognition she has earned across Rhode Island's legal and press communities. In October 2023, the Providence Journal reported her complete NOT GUILTY verdict in the Derek Winslow murder trial — a case where her client's alleged co-conspirators were already serving life sentences.

Her commitment to justice extends to cases that most attorneys decline. She has fought for post-conviction DNA exoneration for a man imprisoned for nearly 40 years, challenged suppression of evidence obtained through unlawful police conduct, and taken complex criminal matters through jury trial when pleading was not in her client's interest.

Published Legal Author
"A Practical Guide to Trying DUI Cases in Rhode Island"
Editor and contributing author of the definitive MCLE guide to DUI defense in Rhode Island — 362 pages covering breath test challenges, field sobriety analysis, motion practice, discovery, jury selection, cross-examination, and trial tactics. Used by attorneys across New England. Published February 2024.
View MCLE Publication →
Both Sides of the Courtroom
Town Solicitor & Criminal Defense — Concurrent Experience
Throughout her career, Attorney Murphy has served as a town solicitor for Rhode Island municipalities — handling criminal prosecution alongside her defense practice. That dual vantage point, prosecuting cases while simultaneously defending them, produces the strategic insight that distinguishes her courtroom preparation from attorneys who have only ever been on one side.
Refusal Defense Expert
Rhodes v. Burrillville — Quoted Authority
Quoted by Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly in the landmark ruling applying the statutory exclusionary rule to Traffic Tribunal civil refusal trials — the first such holding in any jurisdiction. Murphy: "People win in the DUI case because of the exclusionary rule, but lose in the refusal case in the Traffic Tribunal. That is why this case is so important."

High-Stakes Cases. High-Stakes Results.

Attorney Murphy's case record spans murder acquittals to DNA post-conviction exoneration efforts — representing clients where the stakes are highest.

Providence Superior Court · October 2023
State v. Derek Winslow
NOT GUILTY — Complete Murder Acquittal
Attorney Murphy secured a complete NOT GUILTY verdict for Derek Winslow in a four-day jury trial before Superior Court Judge Kristin E. Rodgers — a 2014 murder case involving the shooting death of an East Providence barber. Two alleged co-conspirators were already serving time: one with two consecutive life sentences, the other having pleaded guilty to murder. Complete acquittal on all charges.
Rhode Island Superior Court · 2023–Present
State v. Norberto Andrade
Post-Conviction DNA Exoneration — 38-Year Imprisonment
Appointed by Superior Court Judge Robert D. Krause to represent Norberto Andrade — imprisoned since 1987 on a life sentence with a 25-year habitual offender enhancement for a 1985 rape he has always denied. DNA testing in January 2023 showed that evidence from under the victim's fingernail could not have come from the client. Murphy told the court: "My client has always maintained his innocence, and he is innocent of these charges." She continues to fight for his exoneration.
Rhode Island Superior Court · 2022
State v. Collins Umoh
Post-Trial New Trial Motion — State Misrepresentation Discovered
Represented corrections officer Collins Umoh through a five-day Superior Court trial and, after conviction, hired a private investigator who discovered that the state had materially misrepresented a 2019 witness report during trial. The report contained allegations by a key prosecution witness that were incorrectly described by the prosecutor. Murphy filed a new trial motion arguing the jury would have returned a not guilty verdict with the complete evidence available for cross-examination.
Rhode Island DUI Defense · 20 Years
2,500+ DUI & Chemical Test Refusal Cases
Dismissals · Suppressions · Not Guilty Verdicts
Attorney Murphy has defended more than 2,500 DUI and chemical test refusal cases across every Rhode Island court including the Traffic Tribunal. Her published MCLE guide reflects practical expertise built from hundreds of suppression hearings, breath test challenges, and jury trials. She challenges DRE testimony, field sobriety testing, probable cause for stops, and the constitutional adequacy of rights advisements across all DUI charge types — first offense through third, refusal, and CDL.

14 Consecutive Years of Super Lawyers Recognition

14
Consecutive Years

Rising Star 2012–2018 · Super Lawyers 2019–2025

Super Lawyers is a peer-nomination and independent research process through Thomson Reuters — fewer than 5% of attorneys in any state receive the designation. Attorney Murphy has been selected every year since 2012: first through the Rising Star designation for attorneys under 40 or within their first 10 years of practice, then through full Super Lawyers selection from 2019 forward. Fourteen consecutive years of recognition reflects sustained peer acknowledgment throughout an entire career.

2012 ↑201320142015201620172018 ↑2019 ↑202020212022202320242025

Gold years = Super Lawyers · Muted years = Rising Star designation

Client Rating
Avvo 10.0 Superb — 66 Reviews
Highest possible attorney rating · Criminal Defense & DUI · 4.9 average across all platforms
View Avvo Profile →
Peer Rating
AV Preeminent — Martindale-Hubbell
Highest peer rating for legal ability and ethical standards from the legal profession's most established rating system
National College
National College for DUI Defense
Member of NCDD — the premier national organization for DUI defense attorneys
View NCDD →

The Definitive Rhode Island DUI Defense Guide

MCLE New England

"A Practical Guide to Trying DUI Cases in Rhode Island" — 2nd Edition, 2024

Attorney Murphy is the editor and a contributing author of this 362-page MCLE publication — the most comprehensive guide to DUI defense practice in Rhode Island. Used by prosecutors and defense attorneys throughout New England as the authoritative reference for Rhode Island DUI proceedings, it covers the entire case from stop to verdict.

Topics include: breath test challenges and chemical test refusal; field sobriety test analysis; probable cause for traffic stops; suppression motions and discovery; jury selection; cross-examination of police and expert witnesses; and complete trial tactics. The guide reflects the practical experience of a practitioner who has defended more than 2,500 DUI cases across 20 years.

View MCLE Publication — 2nd Edition 2024 →

Covered Across Rhode Island's Leading
Legal and News Publications

Providence Journal
Jury Acquits Providence Man in 2014 Murder of East Providence Barber
October 21, 2023
The Providence Journal reported Attorney Murphy's complete NOT GUILTY verdict in State v. Derek Winslow — a four-day jury trial before Superior Court Judge Kristin E. Rodgers in which her client was acquitted of a 2014 murder, despite two alleged co-conspirators having already been convicted and sentenced to life in prison.
Read article →
Providence Journal
He Spent Decades in Prison. Now, DNA May Show He Was Right.
January 12, 2023
The Providence Journal featured Attorney Murphy's work representing Norberto Andrade — imprisoned since 1987 on a life sentence for a 1985 rape he has always denied. DNA testing showed evidence could not have come from the client. Murphy told the court: "My client has always maintained his innocence, and he is innocent of these charges." She is fighting to secure his exoneration and release.
Read article →
Providence Journal
Marijuana Is Now Legal in RI, but Driving High Isn't. How Will Police Identify Offenders?
June 10, 2022
The Providence Journal quoted Attorney Murphy as a leading defense voice on drug recognition expert testimony: "I argue all the time, as the defense, that this is the only crime of opinion on the books — not evidence, because it's just an officer's opinion, without a chemical test." She stated she would take DRE marijuana DUI cases to trial rather than pleading out — a position validated by Rhode Island courts.
Read article →
Providence Journal
Ex-Corrections Officer Convicted of Having Sex with Inmates Seeks New Trial
December 16, 2022
The Providence Journal covered Attorney Murphy's post-trial motion in State v. Collins Umoh, where her private investigator discovered that the state materially misrepresented a key witness report during trial. Murphy argued that with the complete evidence available for cross-examination, the jury would have returned a not guilty verdict.
Read article →
Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly
Statutory Exclusionary Rule Applies to 'Refusal' Civil Trials
August 17, 2017
Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly quoted Attorney Murphy as a recognized authority in the landmark Rhodes v. Town of Burrillville ruling — the first decision in any jurisdiction applying a statutory exclusionary rule to Traffic Tribunal civil refusal trials. Murphy explained the practical significance for Rhode Island DUI defense, noting the prior disparity between criminal and civil proceedings that the ruling corrected.
Read article →
Providence Journal
State: DNA Links Perpetrator to 1985 Rape. What the Prosecutors Argue.
October 23, 2023
The Providence Journal reported Attorney Murphy's continued advocacy for Norberto Andrade after the state filed a motion to dismiss his exoneration petition. Murphy is objecting to the state's motion, citing the fingernail sample that excludes Andrade, and is raising ineffective assistance of counsel and additional post-conviction claims in proceedings before Superior Court Judge Robert D. Krause.
Read article →

Teaching Law Enforcement.
Training Fellow Attorneys.

  • Police Academy
    Rhode Island Municipal Police Academy — DUI/DWI Enforcement Instruction 2023 · Formal instruction to police recruits on DUI and DWI enforcement, impaired driving investigations, evidentiary requirements, and constitutional considerations
  • Law Enforcement
    Rhode Island & Connecticut Police Departments — Fourth Amendment & DUI 2013–2015 · Presented to multiple police departments on Fourth Amendment search and seizure, DUI enforcement procedures, and constitutional considerations in criminal investigations
  • CLE
    Roger Williams University School of Law — DUI Defense 2011 · Trained law students entering DUI and criminal defense practice on Rhode Island procedures, client representation, and trial strategy
  • MCLE
    Massachusetts Continuing Legal Education — Second Offense Refusals 2011 · Published guidance on second-offense DUI refusal defense in Massachusetts and Rhode Island for the MCLE New England CLE program
  • Community
    East Greenwich Juvenile Hearing Board — Member Community service through juvenile diversion proceedings · Also served on EGSA Board

20 Years of Rhode Island Criminal Defense

2023–Present
Marin & Murphy Law Firm
Partner
Partner at Marin & Murphy Law Firm following the 2023 merger and rebranding. Leads the firm's criminal defense practice alongside Matthew T. Marin across five Rhode Island offices: East Greenwich, Cranston, Providence, South Kingstown, and Cumberland.
  • NOT GUILTY verdict — State v. Derek Winslow murder trial (2023)
  • Post-conviction DNA exoneration advocacy — State v. Norberto Andrade (2023–present)
  • MCLE DUI defense guide published (2024)
  • Super Lawyers recognition: 2023, 2024, 2025
2011–2023
Law Offices of Stefanie A. Murphy, LLC
Founder & Principal Attorney
Founded solo Rhode Island criminal defense practice in 2011, operating from East Greenwich. Built a recognized practice over 12 years before merging with Attorney Marin in 2023.
  • 2,500+ DUI and criminal cases defended across District Court, Superior Court, Traffic Tribunal, U.S. District Court
  • Quoted by Providence Journal as leading DRE/marijuana DUI defense authority (2022)
  • Quoted by RI Lawyers Weekly in Rhodes v. Burrillville refusal exclusionary rule ruling (2017)
  • Collins Umoh criminal sexual conduct trial and post-trial new trial motion (2022)
  • Super Lawyers Rising Star 2012–2018; Super Lawyers 2019–2022
2005–2011
Rhode Island Criminal Defense Practice
Associate Attorney · Town Solicitor (concurrent)
Practiced criminal defense from her first year following bar admission, handling the full range of criminal matters including DUI, domestic violence, violent crimes, and federal cases. Simultaneously served as a town solicitor for Rhode Island municipalities — prosecuting criminal matters on behalf of local governments while actively defending clients. Admitted to the Rhode Island, Massachusetts, and Connecticut Bars in 2005–2006.

Bar Admissions

Attorney Murphy is admitted to practice in three states and three federal district courts — providing full coverage for clients facing charges in New England state and federal proceedings. Verified credentials & entity data → Firm Facts

Rhode Island
Admitted 2005 · Bar # 7252
Verify RI Bar Record →
Massachusetts
Admitted 2005 · BBO # 663646
Verify MA Bar Record →
Connecticut
Admitted 2006 · Bar # 425823
Verify CT Bar Record →
U.S. District Courts
Federal Criminal Practice
Verify Federal Bar Record →
District of RI
District of MA
District of CT

Academic Background

Juris Doctor
Roger Williams University School of Law
J.D., 2005 · Rhode Island bar admission same year
Bachelor of Arts
College of the Holy Cross
B.A. · Political Science · NCAA Division I Swimmer — Captain, MVP
Early Publication
Rhode Island Bar Journal · 2009
"How to Handle Your First DWI/Refusal Case" — published in the RI Bar Journal in her fourth year of practice.

Organizations & Affiliations

East Greenwich Juvenile Hearing Board & EGSA Board

Attorney Murphy has served on the East Greenwich Juvenile Hearing Board, participating in youth diversion proceedings that provide alternatives to formal prosecution for first-time juvenile offenders. She has also served on the EGSA Board — reflecting her commitment to the East Greenwich community where the firm's flagship office operates.

Criminal Defense Representation

Courts & Jurisdictions
  • RI Superior Court
  • RI District Court
  • RI Traffic Tribunal
  • U.S. District Court (RI, MA, CT)
  • All Rhode Island Counties
  • MA & CT State Courts

Call Attorney Murphy Directly

Free, confidential consultations available 24 hours a day. When you call, you speak with an attorney — not an intake coordinator.

Direct Line (401) 316-9423
Firm Main Line (401) 228-8271
Email Email