Experienced. Aggressive. Trial Lawyers.
★★★★★ 5.0 on Google  ·  (462 reviews)
2026 Award-Winning Criminal Defense Attorneys
Call Now  ·  (401) 269-3381  ·  Available 24/7
Award-Winning Defense
★★★★★ 5.0 Verified Rating
CALL 24/7

Federal Healthcare Fraud Defense Lawyer in Rhode Island

Protecting RI physicians and healthcare professionals facing federal fraud investigations, DOJ prosecution, and parallel False Claims Act exposure.
When federal agents arrive at a medical practice or a physician receives a target letter from the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Rhode Island, the stakes extend far beyond fines or professional sanctions. Federal healthcare fraud charges under 18 U.S.C. § 1347 carry up to ten years in prison per count — or up to twenty years if the fraud resulted in serious bodily injury. The investigation may have been building for years before you became aware of it, and every decision from this point forward affects whether you will practice medicine again and whether your freedom survives intact. Working with an experienced Rhode Island federal criminal defense lawyer from the earliest stage of a healthcare fraud investigation can change what charges are filed and how the case resolves.

2026

Award Winning
Criminal Defense

40+

Years Combined Experience

2,500+

Cases Defended

462+

5-Star Google Reviews as of November 2026

Updated November 2026

⚠️ Federal Healthcare Fraud Prosecutors Build Their Case From Your Own Records.

Subpoenas to CMS. Audits from your MAC. Interviews with your billing staff. A HIPAA search warrant on your practice. Federal healthcare fraud investigations in the District of Rhode Island run quietly for 12 to 24 months before charges are filed — and every claim you submitted is already part of the government’s case file. If your practice has received a subpoena or search warrant, see what steps a healthcare provider faces during a federal investigation — the timeline matters more than most providers realize.

What makes federal healthcare fraud different from a commercial billing audit isn’t the scrutiny — it’s the criminal exposure. Each false claim can produce a separate count. Kickback allegations produce charges under the Anti-Kickback Statute. Stark Law violations become predicate acts. Loss amount drives the guidelines range. And the civil False Claims Act exposure runs in parallel with treble damages and per-claim penalties.

You are behind from the moment of arrest. The only question is how fast you close the gap.

Fill out this form now. You speak directly with a Rhode Island federal healthcare fraud defense attorney — not intake, not a paralegal — who will immediately assess your exposure across criminal, civil, and administrative tracks, and tell you exactly where you stand.

In federal court, waiting isn’t neutral. It’s losing ground.


Healthcare fraud prosecutions are a DOJ priority backed by coordinated investigations involving FBI agents, HHS Office of Inspector General auditors, and specialized prosecutors who handle nothing but healthcare cases. If you are in their sights, you need defense counsel who understands both the medical billing complexities underlying the charges and the federal criminal procedure that governs what happens next.

The decisions you make in the first days after learning of an investigation often determine whether charges are filed at all and whether collateral consequences can be contained. Federal healthcare fraud defense requires specific knowledge, preparation, and the willingness to take these cases to trial when the government’s offer is unacceptable.

Marin & Murphy Law Firm represents physicians, healthcare executives, clinic owners, and billing professionals facing federal healthcare fraud investigations and charges in the District of Rhode Island and surrounding federal districts. Founding partner Matthew T. Marin and trial attorney Stefanie A. Murphy bring the federal court experience, technical preparation, and trial capability these cases demand.

How Do Federal Healthcare Fraud Investigations Begin?

Federal healthcare fraud investigations rarely begin with an arrest. Most start quietly — sometimes years before the target becomes aware. A disgruntled employee files a qui tam complaint under the False Claims Act. An insurance company’s data analytics flags unusual billing patterns. A federal task force reviewing claims data identifies statistical outliers. By the time agents appear at your door or you receive a federal target letter, prosecutors may already possess years of billing records, patient files, and witness statements.

The first indication of a federal healthcare investigation might be a visit from FBI or HHS-OIG agents asking to discuss billing practices. It might be a subpoena demanding production of patient records, employment files, or financial documents. It might be a target letter from the U.S. Attorney’s Office for the District of Rhode Island formally advising that you are under investigation.

Whatever form notification takes, one principle applies: do not speak to federal agents without counsel present. Statements made during what agents describe as a voluntary conversation become evidence. Inconsistencies between what you say and what documents show become the basis for additional charges, including false statements charges under 18 U.S.C. § 1001.

The parallel nature of federal healthcare investigations creates particular complexity. Civil False Claims Act proceedings and criminal prosecutions often run simultaneously. Statements and admissions in one proceeding affect the other. Discovery produced in civil litigation may be shared with criminal prosecutors. Counsel experienced in Rhode Island federal criminal defense must understand both tracks and coordinate strategy across them.

What Are Federal Healthcare Fraud Charges? Statutes, Elements, and Penalties

Federal healthcare fraud encompasses a range of offenses, but the core theory in most prosecutions is straightforward: the government alleges that claims submitted to federal healthcare programs were false, and that the defendant knew they were false when submitting them.

What makes a claim “false” under federal law extends beyond outright fabrication. Upcoding — billing for services more complex or expensive than those actually provided — constitutes fraud. Unbundling — billing separately for services that should be billed together at a lower rate — constitutes fraud. Billing for services not rendered, billing for medically unnecessary services, paying kickbacks for patient referrals in violation of the Anti-Kickback Statute (42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7b), and falsifying documentation to support claims all fall within the federal healthcare fraud statutes.

The government must prove intent: that the defendant knew the claims were false and submitted them anyway with intent to defraud. This is where defense strategy focuses. Billing errors, coding mistakes, ambiguous regulatory guidance, reliance on billing staff or consultants, and good-faith interpretation of complex rules all bear on whether the government can prove the required mental state.

Federal prosecutors do not bring healthcare fraud cases expecting to lose on intent. They build cases methodically using cooperating witnesses who testify to what the defendant knew and directed, pattern evidence showing systematic conduct over time, and expert witnesses who explain why billing practices departed from industry standards.

The sentencing exposure in federal healthcare fraud cases correlates with alleged loss amounts under the federal sentencing guidelines. Prosecutors often aggregate losses across years of billing activity, producing figures in the millions. A loss amount exceeding $1.5 million can push guideline calculations toward five to eight years before enhancements. Loss amounts in the tens of millions can produce guideline ranges exceeding fifteen or twenty years, compounded by enhancements for sophisticated means, large numbers of victims, and abuse of trust.

If you have received a target letter, a subpoena, or a visit from federal agents about your billing practices, the decisions you make now directly affect the outcome. Contact Marin & Murphy Law Firm at (401) 269-3381 for a confidential consultation before responding to investigators.

Federal Bail, Release Conditions, and the Parallel Civil Track

Federal healthcare fraud defendants charged by indictment typically learn of charges when summoned for arraignment at the federal courthouse in Providence. In some cases — particularly those involving allegations of ongoing fraud or flight risk — defendants are arrested. Federal detention hearing decisions turn on whether conditions of release will reasonably assure the defendant’s appearance and community safety. Prosecutors may seek passport surrender, travel restrictions, and limitations on professional practice.

Healthcare providers face an additional layer of consequences that begin before any conviction. Physicians and clinic owners who have already been contacted by federal agents can find a step-by-step response guide on our healthcare provider under federal investigation page. Notice to state licensing boards may trigger disciplinary proceedings. Medicare and Medicaid programs may initiate exclusion proceedings. Hospital privileges may be suspended, and insurer contracts may be terminated. These collateral consequences can destroy a medical practice while the criminal case is still pending.

The civil False Claims Act track runs parallel to criminal proceedings. Qui tam relators — often former employees — stand to receive a percentage of any recovery. Civil exposure compounds the stakes: False Claims Act penalties include treble damages plus per-claim penalties that can exceed the alleged fraud amount itself.

What Evidence Do Federal Prosecutors Use in Healthcare Fraud Cases?

Federal healthcare fraud prosecutions are document-intensive. The evidence that decides these cases includes billing records and claims data, medical records documenting actual services provided, communications revealing what the defendant knew and directed, financial records tracing payments, and testimony from insiders who participated in or observed the alleged scheme.

Claims data analysis forms the backbone of most prosecutions. Government experts compare billing patterns to industry norms, identify statistical anomalies, and calculate alleged overpayments. They map billing codes to medical records, looking for services billed but not documented or documented insufficiently to support the code billed. Medical records also reveal documentation practices: whether records were created contemporaneously, whether they support medical necessity, and whether they were altered after the investigation began.

Cooperating witnesses often provide the most damaging evidence. Former billing staff who describe being directed to upcode. Physicians who participated in kickback arrangements. Patients who testify they never received services for which claims were submitted. Federal prosecutors develop cooperators methodically, often securing cooperation by offering favorable treatment on their own charges — a dynamic that also arises in federal conspiracy defense cases. Electronic evidence — emails, text messages, internal communications — can prove equally significant, carrying timestamps and metadata that corroborate or contradict witness testimony.

Charges Often Filed Alongside Federal Healthcare Fraud

Federal healthcare fraud charges rarely stand alone. Prosecutors routinely bring overlapping counts to maximize sentencing exposure and provide alternative theories for the jury. Common companion charges include:

  • Wire Fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1343): Any claim transmitted electronically — which today includes virtually all insurance billing — supports a separate wire fraud charge carrying up to 20 years per count.
  • Federal Mail Fraud (18 U.S.C. § 1341): Claims or correspondence sent by mail support additional fraud counts with the same 20-year maximum.
  • Federal Conspiracy (18 U.S.C. § 371): Where prosecutors allege multiple participants in a billing scheme, conspiracy charges extend liability to all co-conspirators for acts committed by any member.
  • Money Laundering (18 U.S.C. § 1956): Moving proceeds of healthcare fraud through bank accounts or shell entities can trigger money laundering charges carrying up to 20 years per count.
  • Anti-Kickback Statute Violations (42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7b): Paying or receiving referral fees for patients covered by federal programs is a separate felony carrying up to 10 years per count.
  • False Statements (18 U.S.C. § 1001): Any misrepresentation to federal investigators — even during an informal interview — carries up to 5 years.
  • Aggravated Identity Theft (18 U.S.C. § 1028A): Using patient identifiers without authorization to submit false claims adds a mandatory consecutive two-year sentence.

The layering of charges creates enormous pressure during plea negotiations. Understanding how each count interrelates and which carry the greatest sentencing impact is essential to effective defense. This is where experience with federal white collar crimes defense makes a material difference.

How to Defend Against Federal Healthcare Fraud Charges

Defending federal healthcare fraud charges requires integration of legal strategy, medical and billing expertise, and thorough factual investigation. Early case assessment determines strategic direction: scope of alleged conduct, strength of evidence on knowledge and intent, potential sentencing exposure based on loss amounts, cooperating witness credibility, and documents that contradict the government’s narrative.

Factual investigation parallels and anticipates the government’s case. Defense counsel must understand the billing practices at issue, the regulatory framework governing them, and the specific conduct alleged. This often requires expert consultants who can evaluate medical necessity, coding practices, and industry standards, and forensic accountants who can challenge loss calculations.

Motion practice in healthcare fraud cases frequently focuses on suppression of evidence, particularly where searches of medical practices may have exceeded warrant authority. Attorney Matthew T. Marin’s recognized expertise in Fourth Amendment litigation — his work on search-and-seizure issues has been cited by Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly as shaping criminal procedure law — is directly applicable to challenging warrant execution and evidence-gathering in federal fraud investigations. Challenges to the voluntariness of statements and the adequacy of warnings may also apply.

The decision whether to proceed to trial or negotiate depends on case-specific factors. Some cases present genuine disputes over whether conduct constituted fraud or reflected reasonable interpretation of ambiguous rules. Some involve cooperating witnesses whose credibility can be effectively challenged, or loss calculations that overstate actual harm. Where these factors create reasonable doubt, trial may be appropriate.

Where trial is not advisable, federal plea agreement defense strategy focuses on reducing charges, challenging loss calculations that drive sentencing, preserving the ability to practice medicine, and structuring civil settlements to minimize total financial impact. Post-conviction relief through federal post-conviction relief remains available when trial or sentencing errors occur.

Why Choose Marin & Murphy for Federal Healthcare Fraud Defense?

Federal healthcare fraud prosecutions are complex, resource-intensive, and high-stakes. The government brings experienced prosecutors and extensive investigative resources. Effective defense requires counsel prepared to match that commitment with trial capability and technical preparation across proceedings that may span years.

Attorney Stefanie A. Murphy has handled serious criminal matters in state and federal courts throughout Rhode Island, including cases involving complex evidentiary issues and significant sentencing exposure. Her defense work includes a 2023 murder acquittal documented by the Providence Journal, demonstrating the trial preparation healthcare fraud cases demand. As lead editor of A Practical Guide to Trying DUI Cases in Rhode Island published by MCLE New England, Murphy has demonstrated the ability to master technical subject matter and translate it for judges and juries. Her published criticism of unreliable forensic evidence reflects the same analytical approach required to challenge government billing experts in fraud prosecutions. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. The cases referenced above are described to illustrate the nature of Attorney Murphy’s trial and post-conviction practice. Every case is evaluated on its individual facts, applicable law, jurisdiction, and procedural posture. Post-conviction matters described as ongoing remain in active litigation, and no outcome has been adjudicated.

Attorney Matthew T. Marin contributes constitutional and suppression-motion experience from Rhode Island state courts that is directly applicable to healthcare fraud defense; Attorney Stefanie A. Murphy handles the firm’s federal court appearances. His Fourth Amendment work — challenging the scope of search warrants, the execution of seizures, and the admissibility of evidence obtained through government overreach — has been cited by Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly as influencing criminal procedure law in the state. In healthcare fraud cases, where the government builds its case on records obtained through subpoenas, warrants, and grand jury demands, the firm’s federal search warrant defense capabilities — challenging evidence collection, warrant scope, and seizure execution — can determine what the jury sees. The firm’s federal criminal defense experience provides the procedural grounding these prosecutions require.

Rhode Island Lawyers Weekly has repeatedly identified both Murphy and Marin as attorneys shaping criminal procedure law in Rhode Island, establishing professional authority within the legal community that extends to the federal bar.

Frequently Asked Questions About Federal Healthcare Fraud

What should I do if federal agents contact me about my billing practices?

Do not answer questions or provide documents without first consulting with defense counsel. Our full guide on a federal criminal investigation — what to do walks through the immediate steps you should take before speaking with anyone. Agents may describe the conversation as voluntary or routine, but statements you make can become evidence in a criminal prosecution. Politely decline to discuss the matter until you have had the opportunity to speak with an attorney who can assess your exposure and advise on how to respond.

What is the difference between a target and a subject of a federal investigation?

A “target” is someone the prosecutor has identified as a putative defendant — the investigation has focused on that person and charges are being considered. A “subject” is someone whose conduct falls within the scope of the investigation but who has not been identified as a likely defendant. Status can change as investigations develop. Either designation requires immediate legal representation.

What are the penalties for federal healthcare fraud?

Under 18 U.S.C. § 1347, healthcare fraud carries up to 10 years in prison per count. If the fraud resulted in serious bodily injury to a patient, the maximum increases to 20 years. If a patient died as a result, the sentence can include life imprisonment. When additional charges like wire fraud, conspiracy, or money laundering are included — as they often are — cumulative sentencing exposure can reach decades. Beyond incarceration, penalties include fines, restitution, forfeiture of assets, and exclusion from federal healthcare programs.

Can healthcare fraud charges be resolved without going to trial?

Many federal healthcare fraud cases are resolved through negotiated dispositions — plea agreements on reduced charges, deferred prosecution agreements, or civil settlements without criminal charges. Whether negotiation is appropriate depends on the strength of the government’s evidence, the potential sentencing exposure, and the defendant’s priorities regarding professional licensure and continued practice. Effective negotiation requires credible trial capability — prosecutors make better offers when they believe defense counsel will go to trial.

How are federal sentencing guidelines calculated in healthcare fraud cases?

Understanding federal sentencing guidelines in fraud cases starts with loss amount — the single biggest driver of the offense level and specific offense characteristics such as number of victims, use of sophisticated means, and abuse of a position of trust. Higher loss amounts produce higher offense levels and longer guideline ranges. Challenging the government’s loss calculations — including their methodology for aggregating claims — is often central to limiting sentencing exposure.

Will I lose my medical license if I am charged with healthcare fraud?

A charge alone does not automatically result in license revocation, but conviction on fraud charges typically triggers state licensing board disciplinary proceedings and may result in suspension or revocation. Medicare and Medicaid exclusion may follow conviction, effectively ending the ability to participate in federal healthcare programs even if a state license is retained. Early defense strategy should account for licensure consequences alongside criminal exposure.

What is qui tam litigation and how does it relate to criminal charges?

Qui tam provisions in the False Claims Act allow private individuals — often former employees — to file civil lawsuits on behalf of the government alleging fraud against federal programs. These complaints are filed under seal, and the government investigates before deciding whether to intervene. Qui tam complaints frequently trigger the investigations that lead to criminal charges. Civil and criminal proceedings may run in parallel, with substantial financial exposure in both tracks.

How long do federal healthcare fraud investigations take?

Federal healthcare fraud investigations typically span two to five years before charges are filed. Understanding how the federal grand jury process works and retaining defense counsel before an indictment is issued can reshape the government’s approach to the case. Investigators analyze billing data, interview witnesses, issue subpoenas, and build the case methodically before presenting it to a grand jury. By the time a target becomes aware, prosecutors may already possess extensive evidence — which is why early intervention by defense counsel, even at the investigation stage, can influence whether charges are filed at all.

What is the Anti-Kickback Statute and how does it relate to healthcare fraud?

The Anti-Kickback Statute (42 U.S.C. § 1320a-7b) makes it a federal crime to knowingly pay or receive anything of value in exchange for referrals of patients covered by federal healthcare programs like Medicare or Medicaid. If your case involves Medicare fraud defense specifically, the Anti-Kickback Statute and False Claims Act exposure often run in parallel. Violations carry up to 10 years per count. Kickback allegations frequently accompany healthcare fraud charges because prosecutors argue that tainted referrals render all resulting claims false. The statute has limited safe harbors, and the line between legitimate business arrangements and illegal kickbacks is often where defense strategy focuses. Providers specifically facing Medicare billing allegations should also review our dedicated Medicare fraud defense page for program-specific statutes and penalties.

For a comprehensive overview of federal criminal defense in Rhode Island, including all charge types and the federal defense process, see our D.R.I. federal criminal defense page.

Contact a Federal Healthcare Fraud Defense Lawyer in Rhode Island

If you are facing a federal healthcare fraud investigation or charges in the District of Rhode Island, early intervention by experienced defense counsel can make a substantial difference. Evidence can be preserved, witnesses identified, and strategic decisions made before options narrow.

Marin & Murphy Law Firm provides confidential consultations for physicians, clinic owners, healthcare executives, and billing professionals facing federal healthcare fraud exposure. Attorney Stefanie A. Murphy and founding partner Matthew T. Marin bring the trial experience these serious federal matters require.

Call (401) 269-3381 to discuss your situation confidentially. We represent clients from our offices in Cranston, East Greenwich, South County in state and federal criminal matters throughout Rhode Island, including Providence County, Kent County, Washington County, and Newport County.

Contact Marin & Murphy Law Firm

Over 40 Years of Combined Experience

Founding Partner

Improve The Outcome Of your Case with The Right Experience Behind You.