24/7 Free Consultation – Protect Your License & Avoid Jail Time
Related DUI Resources
Explore these contextual links for more on DUI topics:- Rhode Island DUI Lawyer – Overview of our DUI defense services and experience.
- RI DUI Penalties Details – Comprehensive breakdown of fines and suspensions.
- RI Chemical Test Refusal Penalties – Risks and defenses for test refusals.
- First offense DUI charges in RI – What to expect if it is your first time facing a DUI charge.
- Rhode Island Drug & Controlled Substance DUI Lawyer – Defense for drug DUI charges involving prescription medication, marijuana, and other controlled substances.
- What Happens at a Rhode Island DUI Arraignment? – What to expect at your first court appearance after a DUI arrest, including charges, bail, and next steps.
- What Happens at a Rhode Island DUI Pre-Trial Conference? – What to expect after arraignment, including discovery review, scheduling, and next legal steps.
- What Does It Mean When a Rhode Island DUI Charge Is Dismissed? – Understand what a DUI charge dismissal means in Rhode Island, including reasons, effects on your record and license, refiling risks, and next steps like sealing.
- Second offense DUI charges in RI – What happens if it’s not your first time.
- Felony DUI charges in RI – Severe cases with higher stakes.
- Rhode Island DUI trials – Understanding the trial process and defenses.
- Failed blood tests in RI DUI cases – Challenges to blood test evidence.
- Preliminary breath test refusal charges – Roadside PBT refusals and consequences.
- Field sobriety tests in RI DUI cases – Validity and common challenges.
- Conditional hardship licenses in RI – Driving options during suspension.
- DUI expungement in Rhode Island – Clearing your record after conviction.
- RI DUI FAQs – Answers to common questions.
Charged with DUI in Rhode Island?
Don’t face the legal system alone. Contact the experienced DUI defense attorneys at Marin & Murphy Law Firm for a free consultation. Call (401) 228-8271 Now!The Prosecution’s Case-In-Chief in Rhode Island DUI Trials
During the first phase of a Rhode Island DUI trial, the prosecution presents their case-in-chief. They call witnesses, such as arresting officers, to testify about the stop, field sobriety tests, and any chemical test results. This is their opportunity to build evidence proving impairment beyond a reasonable doubt. Our defense team at Marin & Murphy closely cross-examines these witnesses to highlight inconsistencies, procedural errors, or lack of probable cause, often weakening the state’s case from the start.Defense Motion to Dismiss in RI DUI Cases
At the close of the prosecution’s case, we file a motion to dismiss if the evidence is insufficient. The judge evaluates whether the state has met the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard. In many cases, we’ve successfully argued for dismissal due to flawed breathalyzer calibration or improper arrest procedures, sparing clients from further trial proceedings.Presenting the Defense Case-In-Chief
If the motion to dismiss is denied, we present our defense, including expert witnesses on BAC science or accident reconstruction, and potentially your testimony. With our experience in over 1000’s of cases, we introduce exculpatory evidence to create reasonable doubt, often leading to acquittals or reduced charges.Sentencing Phase After a DUI Conviction in Rhode Island
In the sentencing phase, we advocate for minimal penalties by presenting mitigating factors like your clean record or personal circumstances. Rhode Island DUI laws mandate minimums, but our negotiations have frequently resulted in probation, reduced fines, or community service instead of jail.Appealing a DUI Conviction in Rhode Island
If convicted, you have a short window to appeal. For District Court cases, we can appeal de novo to Superior Court for a new trial. Our firm has successfully overturned verdicts by highlighting legal errors, preserving your rights and record.Secure Your Future with Skilled DUI Defense
Facing a DUI trial in Rhode Island is a serious matter that requires expert legal representation. The complexities of DUI trials—from scientific evidence to legal technicalities—demand an attorney with the knowledge, experience, and dedication to protect your rights. At Marin & Murphy Law Firm, we are committed to providing the aggressive defense you need to fight your DUI charges and secure the best possible outcome. If you’re dealing with DUI charges, don’t leave your future to chance—contact us today at (401) 228-8271 for a free consultation and let us help you navigate the legal process.Key Phases of a Rhode Island DUI Trial
This table outlines the main stages of a typical DUI trial in Rhode Island (most often heard in District Court). Understanding these phases helps highlight defense opportunities at each step.| Phase | Description | Defense Opportunities |
|---|---|---|
| Prosecution Case-in-Chief | The state presents evidence including officer testimony, field sobriety tests, and chemical tests (breath, blood, or urine). | Cross-examine witnesses to expose inconsistencies, lack of probable cause, or improper testing procedures. |
| Motion to Dismiss | Defense moves to dismiss if the evidence fails to meet the “beyond a reasonable doubt” standard. | Challenge sufficiency of evidence such as invalid stops or faulty breathalyzer calibration — many cases end here. |
| Defense Case-in-Chief | Defense presents witnesses, experts, or testimony to establish reasonable doubt. | Introduce BAC experts, medical explanations, or accident reconstruction evidence. |
| Sentencing Phase | Judge determines penalties based on statutory minimums and mitigating factors. | Argue for probation, reduced fines, or community service instead of jail. |
| Appeal | Short window to appeal District Court verdicts de novo to Superior Court. | Challenge legal errors and preserve the client’s record and rights. |
Meet Our Experienced Rhode Island DUI Trial Lawyers
MATTHEW T. MARIN, ESQ.
PARTNER
- Successfully argued for suppression of breath test results in landmark 2015 Rhode Island District Court cases (including State v. Zimmerman), challenging the adequacy of the state’s DUI Rights for Motorists form— leading to multiple judicial rulings finding the form misleading and ultimately prompting the Rhode Island Attorney General’s Office to revise the form statewide to better inform motorists of their rights under amended DUI laws
- Through a firm associate, successfully argued and prevailed in the Rhode Island Supreme Court case State v. Corcoran (R.I. 2022), affirming the suppression of incriminating statements in a DUI investigation—establishing key precedent that roadside questioning after a collision and failed sobriety tests constitutes custodial interrogation requiring Miranda warnings, significantly strengthening protections for defendants in impaired driving cases statewide. Successfully argued by Attorney Marin in the Washington County Superior Court.
- Member of the prestigious National College for DUI Defense (NCDD)
- Handled thousands of DUI cases, focusing on breath, blood, and urine test challenges
- Selected to Super Lawyers every year since 2014 | National Trial Lawyers Top 100
- Avvo Rating: 10.0 “Superb” | Martindale-Hubbell: AV Preeminent
- Featured in Rhode Island Bar Journal articles on DUI defense strategies
- Admitted to the Rhode Island Supreme Court (2008) and U.S. District Court for Rhode Island
- Deep expertise in 2025 RI DUI law changes, including the expanded 10-year look-back period
STEFANIE A. MURPHY, ESQ.
PARTNER
- Lead editor and contributing author of the authoritative A Practical Guide to Trying DUI Cases in Rhode Island (2nd Edition 2024, MCLE New England), a comprehensive legal resource offering in-depth analysis, practical guidance, current case law, statutory authorities, sample pleadings, checklists, and proven strategies for defending and prosecuting DUI cases in Rhode Island—essential for attorneys navigating complex drunk driving litigation in the state
- Invited by the Rhode Island Municipal Police Training Academy to lecture and demonstrate DUI trial practice and defense strategies to incoming municipal police recruits—sharing in-depth knowledge of Rhode Island DUI prosecution and defense tactics with future law enforcement officers statewide, underscoring her recognized expertise in impaired driving litigation
- Extensive courtroom experience defending DUI and serious criminal charges including Second Offense DUI Charges and Felony DUI Charges
- Focus on achieving charge dismissals and reductions for clients
- Avvo Rating: 10.0 | Martindale-Hubbell Peer Rating: 4.6/5.0
- Recognized for outstanding results across a broad spectrum of criminal cases
- Expertise in 2025 RI DUI law updates and aggressive trial representation
- Advanced training in criminal defense and DUI litigation
- Admitted to the Rhode Island Supreme Court (2004) and U.S. District Court for Rhode Island
Frequently Asked Questions About DUI Trials in Rhode Island
How long does a Rhode Island DUI trial last?
A typical DUI trial in Rhode Island District Court lasts 1–3 days, depending on the number of witnesses and the complexity of the evidence. Jury trials—though rare for DUI cases—can extend to a week or longer.
Do most DUI cases in Rhode Island go to trial?
No. More than 90% of Rhode Island DUI cases resolve through plea negotiations. Trials usually occur when evidence is strongly contested or when charges carry significant consequences.
What is the burden of proof in a Rhode Island DUI trial?
The prosecution must prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt, which is the highest burden of proof in criminal law.
Can I testify in my own Rhode Island DUI trial?
Yes, but doing so is a strategic decision. Your attorney will advise whether testifying helps or hurts your case, especially given the risks of cross-examination.
Will a jury decide my Rhode Island DUI case?
Most DUI trials in Rhode Island are bench trials decided by a judge in District Court. Jury trials are available only if the case is appealed to Superior Court.
What happens if I’m found not guilty in a Rhode Island DUI trial?
If found not guilty, the DUI charge is dismissed. There is no conviction on your criminal record, and you avoid penalties such as license suspension, fines, or probation.
Can new evidence be introduced during a Rhode Island DUI trial?
Generally no. Evidence must be disclosed during pre-trial discovery. Surprise evidence is uncommon due to strict disclosure rules.
How does cross-examination work in Rhode Island DUI trials?
Defense attorneys cross-examine police officers and witnesses to challenge the legality of the stop, accuracy of testing, and reliability of observations, often creating reasonable doubt.
Is video evidence always used in Rhode Island DUI trials?
Often, yes. Dash camera and body camera footage is frequently introduced. Defense counsel reviews videos carefully for inconsistencies, procedural errors, or rights violations.
What role do expert witnesses play in Rhode Island DUI trials?
Expert witnesses may testify regarding BAC science, breath and blood testing accuracy, field sobriety test reliability, or medical conditions affecting test results.
Can I appeal a guilty verdict from a Rhode Island DUI trial?
Yes. A District Court DUI conviction can be appealed de novo—meaning a new trial—before the Rhode Island Superior Court within the required filing deadline.
How does a motion to dismiss work in Rhode Island DUI trials?
A motion to dismiss may be filed after the prosecution rests if the evidence is legally insufficient. Many DUI cases end at this stage if the state fails to meet its burden.
What are common defenses in Rhode Island DUI trials?
Common defenses include improper traffic stops, faulty breath or blood tests, medical conditions affecting performance, improper administration of field sobriety tests, and rising BAC defenses.
Do I need a lawyer for a Rhode Island DUI trial?
Strongly recommended. DUI trials involve complex legal standards, scientific evidence, and procedural rules. Self-representation significantly increases the risk of conviction.
Can charges be reduced before a Rhode Island DUI trial?
Yes. Through skilled negotiation and pre-trial litigation, charges are often reduced to lesser offenses such as reckless driving, avoiding the need for trial.
